Without a healthy compressor, your air conditioning system loses all of its cooling power. From strange grinding sounds to tripped circuit breakers, recognizing the signs of compressor failure helps you avoid further system damage and choose between AC unit compressor replacement vs. repair.
Signs Your AC Compressor Is the Reason You’re Not Getting Cold Air
The compressor represents the outdoor portion of your AC system. By circulating and pressurizing refrigerant, the compressor facilitates the cooling process and allows your system to extract heat from inside and release it outside.
AC compressor issues typically present in specific ways. If your AC compressor is running but not cooling, checking your compressor for these signs helps you identify and resolve the problem.
Loud or unusual noises
Strange sounds from the outdoor unit may signal mechanical failures inside the compressor. Grinding or rattling noises often indicate broken or loose components, such as worn bearings or damaged rods. Buzzing or humming noises suggest electrical problems, such as arcing. Persistent or worsening noises may result in full compressor failure and damage to other AC components if left unaddressed.
Circuit breaker keeps tripping
If the circuit breaker for the compressor’s circuit repeatedly trips, the compressor may be over-drawing current. This happens during hard starts when internal components are strained or the compressor motor overheats. A grounded terminal, failed internal motor, or shorted winding can all overload the system.
Outdoor unit vibrates or stalls when starting
Mechanical blockages or locked-up rotors may cause the outdoor unit to shake aggressively or fail to start smoothly. This condition, known as a hard start, means the compressor is struggling to initiate rotation due to underlying problems.
Repeated hard starts strain the system by drawing excessive power and overheating the compressor. Ongoing stalling reduces efficiency, accelerates wear, and may lead to premature AC replacement.
Compressor isn’t turning on
If the indoor blower fan runs but the outdoor unit is silent or unresponsive, the compressor may have failed. Other AC issues may indirectly prevent the compressor from turning on by triggering safety sensors, which prompt compressor shutdowns when they detect overheating and other abnormalities. These shutdowns protect the compressor, and they may require a technician to reset the system before it can operate again.
Ice buildup
Ice buildup on the refrigerant lines or the condenser coil suggests that the compressor is struggling to circulate refrigerant. If the refrigerant doesn’t move efficiently through the system, the evaporator coils may become too cold and cause nearby condensation to freeze. This further inhibits heat exchange, limits your AC’s cooling capacity, and increases the risk of overheating.
How to Know If You Need AC Unit Compressor Replacement
Compressors are complex systems, and not all instances of internal damage are worth repairing. A full replacement may be necessary for severe or permanent damage, while more minor repairs usually involve replacing smaller components.
When to repair
If your technician determines that external components contributed to compressor problems, repairing those components may likewise resolve issues with the compressor. Addressing these issues quickly can restore cooling performance and prolong your system’s operating life without a major investment.
AC compressor repair is typically more practical than replacement if:
- The compressor doesn’t show signs of internal damage.
- Repairs are minor and significantly less costly than replacement.
- The system is less than 10 years old and in good condition.
When to replace
Repairs aren’t always possible, particularly for internal compressor damage. In this case, replacing the compressor is a better long-term solution. Replacement may also be preferable if the compressor is old, outdated, or no longer covered under warranty. A licensed HVAC technician can troubleshoot your system and provide a detailed estimate of compressor repair vs. replacement.
AC Compressor Working But No Cold Air? It Might Be Something Else
Not every cooling issue originates with the compressor. Many problems may present as compressor failure when they’re actually a symptom of another issue within your system. If the AC compressor is working but not cooling, the issue is likely caused by another part of the system.
Capacitor or Contactor Failure
Capacitors and contactors regulate power to the compressor. If they malfunction, the compressor may struggle or fail to start or may stop working unexpectedly mid-cycle. A failed start capacitor won’t give the compressor its required start-up boost, while a bad contactor prevents power from reaching the motor.
Low refrigerant
Refrigerant leaks reduce system pressure and prevent proper heat transfer. The compressor may still run, but it won’t have enough refrigerant to pressurize and circulate effectively.
Refrigerant circulates within a closed system and doesn’t deplete, so low refrigerant usually points to a leak in the line. Low refrigerant causes symptoms similar to compressor failure, such as ice buildup or irregular cooling cycles. Professional refrigerant leak detection, repair, and recharging can resolve these issues.
Frozen or dirty coils
The evaporator coil absorbs heat from indoor air, and it can’t transfer heat properly if it’s dirty or frozen. Likewise, dirty condenser coils can’t release heat outdoors efficiently. In either case, your system may blow warm or slightly cool air until a thorough coil cleaning restores it to normal function.
Thermostat issues
If a faulty thermostat misreads indoor temperatures and sends incorrect signals to the control board, the unit may cycle on and off at the wrong times or never reach the cooling setpoint. Thermostat malfunctions may not affect the compressor directly, but they can limit its effectiveness and strain your overall system.
Airflow obstructions
Your AC requires consistent airflow to maintain performance. Blocked ducts, closed vents, and dirty air filters may restrict circulation, causing the compressor to work harder to meet cooling demands. In some cases, restricted airflow may cause breaker trips and overheating.
Replacing the Compressor vs. Replacing the Entire AC Unit
Many homeowners who face compressor failure opt to replace the entire AC unit rather than individual components. Once your technician confirms compressor problems, they can walk you through the advantages of compressor vs. AC replacement.
Advantages of compressor replacement
Compressor replacement frequently rivals the cost of installing a new AC system, but replacing the compressor may be a practical choice if the system is relatively new and in good condition. Many manufacturers also offer warranties that may cover eligible compressor failure claims.
Advantages of AC replacement
A new AC system often offers better long-term performance, reliability, and value. Consult with an HVAC technician about replacing your AC system if your equipment is old, outdated, or in poor condition. Compressor failure is often a sign that your system is broadly worn out and approaching the end of its operating life, and proactive replacement may lower the risk of a sudden AC failure.
Modern AC systems also offer improved technology and seasonal energy efficiency ratio (SEER) ratings, and upgrading to a new unit may translate to cost savings on your energy bills.
Trust Local Experts at Fleetwell for HVAC Repairs
When your air conditioner isn’t cooling, rely on the Fleetwell’s HVAC team. Our technicians provide accurate diagnostics, same-day repair options, and expert recommendations to help inform your cooling system decisions. We serve homeowners throughout Southern California, including Los Angeles, Orange County, and San Bernardino County. Contact us or schedule an inspection online.
